The populism, mythmaking and success of Donald Trump

Donald Trump embodies the American Dream. He was an underdog in a way that his more experienced opponent, Hillary Clinton, was not. The media criticized him relentlessly, but he still became President of the United States due to the support he cultivated. The American Dream is the idea that a person can achieve great things without having the same resources and connections that others might. When a political outsider wins our nation’s highest office, that is the American Dream in action.

I do not actually believe what I wrote above. I would especially like to emphasize that I do not think Trump is an “underdog.” While much media coverage of Trump was negative during his first campaign, as a result of his outlandish behavior, the odds in that field certainly were not stacked against him. According to The Street, Trump received almost five billion dollars in free media coverage during 2016 through his use of X, formerly Twitter. While Trump did not start with the same political connections as most presidential candidates, he certainly had enough fame and wealth from the private sector to leverage the support of powerful people. It is difficult for Trump to fit a rags-to-riches story when the “rags” include golden buildings with his name on them. 

The Trump campaign omits facts of his character and experience to paint Donald Trump favorably. More than that, there’s an effort to mythologize Trump by tying him to the American Dream. The American Dream is not a provable concept, but rather a story that many Americans hope will come true. And if Trump’s story can align with the American Dream, he can legitimize that narrative. This makes his campaign resonate with voters. This mythmaking is an essential component of populism, a tactic that frames a leader as a man of the people, and all opposition as part of an elite that does not represent the people’s interests. 

Donald Trump associates himself with many popular myths and stories. When he describes China, he always mentions how he will return manufacturing jobs to the US. The outsourcing of jobs has left many Americans without work, while China’s rapid growth sparks people’s fears of their future economic domination. Trump repeatedly mentions China because he wants to portray himself as a winner of the game of international economic competition. He, and by extension America, becomes the hero, while China is the villain. However, according to Bloomberg, Trump does not accomplish what he promises. Under his administration, 184,888 jobs are estimated to have been offshored by China. 

In many places, Trump has consistently blamed American joblessness and its downturn on either foreign countries or foreign immigrants, adding a xenophobic angle to his mythmaking. When Trump tells people that the economic success of immigrants comes at the expense of American citizens, he is failing to address true solutions in order to get more votes. Not only that, but his lies create a hostile environment for the groups that Trump disparages.

To many Democrats, Trump’s statements are outrageous. The fact that such a solid portion of the population believes him and supports him is baffling. But Trump’s lies have a foundation in real problems that America faces. Manufacturers in the US have indeed outsourced labor to other countries since the ’90s, leaving many without reliable jobs. Economic crises from 2008 and the disruptions from the pandemic have upended the lives of many Americans. The government has not always stepped up to meet these needs. Trust in the federal government, according to the Pew Research Center, has been in decline for 20 years, with 65 percent of subjects believing that government officials serve their own interests rather than voters. If citizens feel that Establishment politicians have not helped them, this makes them friendlier to leadership options from outside the corrupt system—or options who appear to be outside the corrupt system. Donald Trump addresses these concerns, but instead of moving to fix them, he preaches a false view of reality that reaffirms nationalism and distrust of the Establishment. By validating these pre-existing feelings, Trump gains a base of support that will be loyal to him even as his behavior grows more and more outrageous.

Is there something that Trump’s opposition can do to counter the political mythmaking that gives him so much support? I believe the answer is yes, but beating him in the upcoming election will not be enough. President Joe Biden beat Donald Trump in 2020, but that has clearly not weakened the latter’s support. The Democratic nominee, Vice President Kamala Harris has captured many voter interests in a short amount of time. The Harris campaign has recently emphasized its endorsement from Republican figures like Dick and Liz Cheney, with sights on bringing in disaffected Republican voters. 

As opposed to Trump, who seems to be doubling down with his existing voter base, Harris is trying to grow and diversify hers. This is obviously a good strategy during elections. It also means that if she wins, she will have to deliver on the many promises she made to that large base of constituents. People will need to see tangible improvement in their lives, particularly in healthcare and jobs. According to Northeastern Global News, the inflation rate is currently down but prices, particularly of food, are still high due to supply chain issues. If Harris fixes these economic issues, she would also be directly disproving the economic discontents of Trump’s populism. 

The cultural discontents of Trump’s populism, meaning the discontents with globalism, the urban-rural divide, and race and gender, will not disappear. However, if citizens feel that their leaders are directly improving their lives, they will have less reason to embrace or accept the hostility in Trump’s rhetoric. If Harris can make and deliver on her promises, populist mythmaking will have fewer frustrations to draw upon. Likewise, if the Harris Administration cannot effectively help Americans, Trump can continue to leverage hostility while juxtaposing himself as a savior. Trump gains his power by prescribing distorted myths for real problems. If the Democrats want to overcome this, they must prescribe solutions.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

The Miscellany News reserves the right to publish or not publish any comment submitted for approval on our website. Factors that could cause a comment to be rejected include, but are not limited to, personal attacks, inappropriate language, statements or points unrelated to the article, and unfounded or baseless claims. Additionally, The Misc reserves the right to reject any comment that exceeds 250 words in length. There is no guarantee that a comment will be published, and one week after the article’s release, it is less likely that your comment will be accepted. Any questions or concerns regarding our comments section can be directed to Misc@vassar.edu.