If the last few months and weeks in America have taught us anything, it is that we are a nation obsessed with aesthetics. In the age of instant media and blink-and-you-will-miss-it culture, many people turn to something more abstract to ascertain their surroundings and the general zeitgeist around them. To put it simply, they do a vibe check. And since the election, there has been an, in my opinion, worrying trend developing: the idea that there is an objectively correct aesthetic that all Americans should strive for and let take hold of their identity. There is an understanding that the way forward is purity of soul and obedience to the religion of the American Dream as interpreted thinly by white-fence America. Think of Donald Trump Jr.’s recent Tweet that racked up 200,000 likes and engagement from Elon Musk: “Biological & objectively attractive women are allowed to win beauty pageants again. WE ARE SO BACK!!!” It is this culture war on our doorsteps that has led me to say you should take some time out of your day to watch the 1996 film “The Birdcage.”
At its core, “The Birdcage” is a fun ’90s adaptation of “La Cage aux Folles” starring a great cast led by Nathan Lane and Robin Williams, wherein they play a Miamian gay couple who own a club named The Birdcage and whose son Val is bringing his fiancée’s conservative senator of a father to come and meet them. That is the surface level. It is filled with many scenes of Lane acting his heart out as the flamboyant Albert, matched perfectly by Williams as the charming and calm Armand. Gene Hackman plays a funny side role as the conservative senator Kevin Keeley, and the movie centers around how Armand and Albert have to juggle their identities to best accommodate someone who has made a successful political career out of being a proponent of traditional American values.
Much of the film focuses on Armand and Val trying to disguise Albert as a straight man. They see his expressiveness and sociality as difficult to conceal, and his identity and its connection to aesthetics is a central tenet of the plot. How does one blend into the “normal” when their identity does not fit neatly into the set paradigm of our society? An almost cartoonishly and overdone solution, which you might have seen in nearly every Disney or Pixar film of the last decade, is to just “own it.” The quirkiness central to one’s identity that sets them apart can be accepted and loved, and trying to squash it out is a fruitless effort that will only cause more problems than it solves. Assimilation is unachievable, and your aesthetic will be loved if you love yourself. But we do not live in a Disney cartoon; we are in the much less-colorful real world. “The Birdcage” offers a much more radical answer, which is that maybe we are the problem. That possibly our interpretation of identity and the aesthetics of life in America are superficial and often led by arbitrary self-imposed rules, and by attaching a gravitational pull to an “ideal path,” we just hurl ourselves into misery.
Armand tries to create a fictitious setting to accommodate Val’s new in-laws, the biggest element of which includes recruiting Val’s biological mother Katherine, whom Val has never actually met. Arman visits Katherine with Albert, and when Albert catches a glimpse of the two being friendly and discussing their past, he storms off in a fit of anger. Though mainly another way for the plot to show Albert’s emotional sensitivity, it also shows how the push towards normativity bloodies everyone in its wake, even those like Armand who live authentically as themselves. Albert is the only character who is unable fully to conceal himself in a fake aesthetic and identity, leaving him excluded even by his life partner. The push towards conformity consumes those who can hide and leaves those who cannot wide in the open. But why should a couple such as these two men have to conform and hide in America?
Armand and Albert are not actually that different from the average American family, as represented by the parents of Val’s fiancée Barbara, and they are also very successful. They have a functioning family unit and a successful business in a vibrant neighborhood where they have friends and happiness. It is the interpretation by Senator Keeley that places Armand and Albert in their state of unnaturalness. Though mainly played for laughs, there are so many profound takeaways from the interactions between the oblivious Keeley and Albert, who is dressed in drag playing Val’s mother. When faced with a manifestation of what he would see as perversion and appropriation of the classic American housewife, Keeley feels comfort and befriends the man in drag, not knowing fiction from fact. It is funny, yes, but it begins the final message of “The Birdcage” surrounding identity and aesthetics: The film concludes that these concepts are only as real as we make them. What struck me especially was the scene where, to escape the media, Albert and Armand dress up Keeley in drag. Not only is it kind of scary that a movie of this caliber could probably not get away with a scene like in the coming years due to its depiction of drag on a conservative politician, but it is also a bizarre and complex thing for the film to put right in front of the audience. That being a representation of conservative politicians and middle America transformed in a moment into a man in drag in a Miami nightclub. It is also funny, yes, but the image is radical in showing that one’s identity and the aesthetics surrounding it are arbitrary. Keeley does not have a heartfelt speech that explains how people so different can live side by side; he becomes accepting by taking part in culture in a way that is not restricted by superficial means.
Ideally, Armand and Albert should not have to hide in our nation. “The Birdcage” is a uniquely American take on how there are certain authenticities in individuals that cannot be hidden, yet American society often pushes people to put these aspects away. It is a sad fact that the varied and happy life that Armand and Albert lead, and do not shy away from by the end of the film, is not included or even looked down upon in the romanticized, clean aesthetic that the coming American culture wars. An America that looks more like Keeley’s and less like Armand’s Birdcage club would likely get a “We’re so back!” from Donald Trump Jr., even though both are perfectly valid.