I have noticed a common complaint among students, administrators and everyone else: College students are unwilling to debate and disagree with each other. Whether it is about politics, campus issues or anything else significant, confrontation is generally avoided. If nobody debates anything, it gives the impression that students of the college agree on everything, which prompts commentators to start calling colleges “echo chambers.” But this label can oversimplify things. Even Vassar, a smaller school, contains a lot of different backgrounds and beliefs. So the diversity of thought is already there, it is just not on full display because of social pressures.
Enter Fizz, an anonymous chat platform that localizes itself to school communities. Vassar students have used it for a little over a year now to complain about fire alarms, drop the initials of their campus crushes and say what they want without anyone knowing their identity. When I first downloaded it my freshman year, I wondered if the anonymous aspect would reveal how students truly thought of the world and one another. It has been a year now. Has Fizz freed up the discourse? Does the app reflect the unfiltered beliefs of the student body?
It does not.
When you make a Fizz post, it can be upvoted or downvoted. The more upvotes a post gets, the more likely it is to be put on the “Fizzin’” section, where it will attract greater attention and more upvotes. This system has secured an early meme about Gordon Commons tables as the top Fizz post of all-time. It is the first image that new users see, and it can effectively farm upvotes from everyone. A user who makes a popular post will get complimented, both by the people who comment and the app itself. For example, if a post reaches 150 upvotes, you get a notification that says “Your mom must be so proud!” Upvotes themselves also get translated into “Karma” for the user. Users with high Karma can be visible on a scoreboard. Fizz accomplishments are seen as real accomplishments. I have friends who show off their posts and appear genuinely proud of all the upvotes they have gotten.
The posts that generally get likes are: Jokes about campus, complaints about campus and relatable personal drama. These posts are seemingly written to be agreeable and short because they generate upvotes. This is not to say that all Fizz content falls into this filter. I have seen people debate issues in the comments section of posts, but judging by the lack of upvotes on them, it is clear that not everyone is actually reading all these things. The Fizz algorithm popularizes that which is short, simple and palatable to social norms. Anything else falls by the wayside.
“Rage bait” is a common occurrence. Rage bait is when someone posts with the goal of inciting outrage. Since regular Fizz users know what is popular, they also know what is unpopular. Topics include stolen jokes, support for Donald Trump, admissions of cheating, disrespectful dating behavior, etc. Any post with negative votes and five or more comments is usually accused of being rage bait. It is always hard to tell what is intentionally posted to make people mad, and what may be a genuinely-held unpopular opinion since the poster does not usually elaborate. Both the presence and perception of rage bait, however, have eroded the spirit of good-faith disagreement.
People do not always stick to inconsequential topics of debate. On the day when an unknown student graffitied pro-Palestinian messaging onto major buildings last semester, Fizz users were unable to ignore the topic. But the majority of the posts were noise complaints, grumbling and brief backlash to said grumbling. Discussions about the wider issue of violence in the Middle East were often ignored or buried under a sea of surface-level posts. The graffiti was soon washed off, and conversations did not continue. All in all, there were more posts about a polycule (a friend group connected through relationships) engaging in public displays of affection at Gordon Commons than the graffiti.
I am not accusing Vassar students of thinking that polycules are more important than politics, but it is clear that if students truly want to discuss controversial topics, they do so in spaces other than Fizz. The potential for a broad audience is outweighed by the large amount of easy competition. It’s obvious that nobody’s going to change their minds based on short-form Fizz posts that are easy to scroll past. There’s no trust that people will engage with posts in good faith. Those who advocate for broader political causes do so by organizing events, talking to classmates, and speaking on platforms that give them more of a space. Fizz is not one of those platforms.
Fizz does not create strong discourse. If a user cannot gain popularity, their posts are buried. If someone posts something disagreeable, it is assumed to be rage bait and ignored. Anyone who wants more substantial debate has given up looking for it on Fizz. The app has the remarkable ability to self-censor anything that does not fit its brand of meme-ified gossip. At the end of the day, Fizz rewards upvotes, not substance.
